Skip to content

insight

Who signs off the work?

"The fee-earner checked it" is not an answer a regulator accepts. Supervision needs a named person, a recorded decision, and evidence you can produce later.

Ali Ahsak2 min read

A firm that cannot say who approved a piece of work does not have a supervision problem in the abstract. It has an evidence problem. When a complaint, a file review, or a regulatory visit arrives, the question is rarely “did someone look at this?” It is “who took responsibility, when, and on what basis?”

The fee-earner check is not supervision

Junior lawyers and paralegals should check their own work. That is professionalism, not governance. Supervision is a different act: a competent person with authority reviews the substance, accepts the risk, and is prepared to defend the decision later.

Collapsing those two steps into “the fee-earner checked it” creates a fiction. The person closest to the draft is often the least able to see what they have normalised. Regulators care about the second pair of eyes — and whether that pair of eyes was real.

Named accountability beats process theatre

Policies that say “all AI output must be reviewed” without naming a reviewer produce theatre. A checklist without a signature is not an audit trail. A Slack reaction is not a decision record.

What holds up under scrutiny is narrower and clearer:

  • a Named Authorised Individual
  • a defined scope of what they approved
  • a timestamp that cannot be rewritten quietly
  • the version of the output that left the firm

If any of those are missing, you are reconstructing history — and reconstruction is where firms lose arguments they thought they had won.

What “sign-off” has to mean in practice

Sign-off is not a rubber stamp at the bottom of an email. It is a commitment that a particular person accepted a particular risk on a particular matter. That commitment has to survive staff changes, tool changes, and the temptation to tidy the file after the fact.

For AI-assisted work the bar is the same as for any other work product. The model does not sign. The firm’s authorised lawyer does. If the tooling cannot show that distinction cleanly, the tooling is not ready for regulated practice.

Design for the review you will actually face

The useful test is not “would this look good in a demo?” It is “could we produce, in a week, a coherent account of who approved what left the firm last quarter?” Firms that can answer that question sleep better. Firms that cannot are one complaint away from discovering that informal culture does not convert into evidence.